My Wife’s Friends Made Me Lose the Cookie Game

We had a group of friends who joined us for game nights. Mike, that’s me, I’m thirty-four, six foot two, and one hundred eighty pounds. I’m in very good shape from lifting three times a week and running the trails near our house in the suburbs of Atlanta. Kimberly is my wife. She is thirty-two and drop-dead gorgeous, five foot four with a thin waist, perfect C-cup boobs that sit high and firm, a beautiful face with full lips, and long blonde hair that brushes the small of her back when she lets it down. Nick and Lauren are both extremely attractive and our best friends from the group. Nick stands a little shorter than me at about six feet and stays in great shape with broad shoulders and thick arms. Kimberly told me after our first swap that his dick was about eight inches, slightly bigger than my seven. The real difference showed in the girth. She could barely get her hand around it, her fingers not quite meeting as she stroked him that first time. Lauren is beautiful too. She is five foot five with a medium build and huge D-cup tits that bounce when she walks, red curly hair to her shoulders, and freckles scattered across her chest and cheeks. Ric is about five foot eight and a solid one hundred fifty pounds, lean from all the hiking he does. Gianna is a beautiful dark-haired Italian girl, five foot one, very thin, with B-cup tits that fit perfectly in your palms. Marcus and Simone are a light-skinned Black couple who look stunning. He stands about six foot two and one hundred eighty pounds, all muscle from his construction job. Simone is tall at five foot nine with a medium build and lovely C-cup tits, dark nipples that get hard quick when she’s turned on. She has a beautiful face and perfect body that makes every guy stare. Jason and Jennifer are Asian American. Jason is about five foot seven and thin but works out and runs, keeping his stomach flat. Jennifer makes him look tall at only five feet. She has a very pretty face and a great smile that stays on display, always ready to laugh. She is very thin with small A-cup tits that are sensitive as hell. Callum and Sophie are originally from Australia but moved to the USA for work after college. Callum is six foot four and weighs about two hundred pounds, built like a linebacker. Sophie is also tall at five foot ten. She has blonde hair and a medium build with nice C-cup tits that she loves to have sucked. Both look like they came straight off an Australian Olympic swim team, though they didn’t. Their skin always smells like sunscreen and salt even months after the last beach trip.

Oral Circle Begins

Every Friday night we rotate game nights through our houses. The guys play poker in one room while the wives play Mahjongg in another. We drink and unwind from the work week, cold beers sweating on the table while we talk shit about our bosses and the Braves game from the night before. After the games we all chill in the living room, music low, lights dimmed. Everyone is in their early thirties, we have good jobs, and none of us have kids yet so the nights run late without anyone rushing home. Twice a year the group raises the stakes. Instead of a twenty-five-dollar buy-in, the buy-in is your wife. We strip down and trade partners for the whole evening, bodies sliding together on the big sectional until everyone is spent and grinning.

Kimberly and I returned home after our incredible evening. She said that was amazing and she could not wait for another six months. I knew the feeling, my cock already twitching again just hearing her describe how full Nick had made her feel. I wished we did it more often than twice a year, but doing it all the time would make it less special, like the excitement would fade into routine. We put the discussion to bed and went to sleep. We were exhausted, limbs tangled, the smell of sex still on our skin.

In the morning the group chat was busy. Everyone commented about the great time and said they could not wait for the next one. As the work week went on I kept thinking about the event and the comments, replaying the sounds of moans and skin slapping in my head during boring meetings. I went on the chat and asked if we could do something between the big events. Everyone seemed interested. We did not want to repeat the full event. We wanted to keep that special. Maybe something smaller could end a regular game night. We agreed to think about it and talk on Friday.

We started our usual poker game and Callum said he and Sophie had an idea. Sophie would discuss it with the ladies while Callum told us. The idea was an oral circle. We would form a circle with our spouse opposite us. A man would sit on either side of each woman and vice versa. We would lie down with our heads clockwise. Each woman would give head to the man on her left while receiving head from the man on her right. If we liked it we could rotate each week for different partners. The guys bought in right away. Who would turn down a blow job from one of these women? The ladies bought in too. At the end of the evening we met in the living room and formed the circle. Starting with me, to my left was Lauren, then Ric, Simone, Jason, Sophie, Nick, Kimberly, Marcus, Gianna, Callum, and Jennifer on my right.

There was a little awkwardness. We had all been with each other the week before, but that night had buildup. This time we were diving straight in. Still, nobody complained. We stripped and took our positions. The men faced inward while the ladies faced outward. We adjusted for access and began. With Lauren on my left I worked on her pussy with my fingers and tongue. I teased rather than going straight for her clit, circling her folds, tasting how she got wetter by the second. Jennifer on my right worked on my dick and did an excellent job, her tongue flat and warm as she licked from base to tip. We all teased at first to prolong the feeling. Lauren moistened quickly. I could tell she was getting excited, her hips shifting toward my mouth. I was too, my cock throbbing in Jennifer’s grip. I shifted focus to her clit. Jennifer hit the spot just below the head of my penis at the same time. She pressed harder with her tongue. I could not hold back. I shot stream after stream into her mouth, hot cum pulsing out while she swallowed every drop. When I could focus again I went full force on Lauren’s clit. She was ready. I sucked on it with pressure all around. She climaxed in seconds, her thighs clamping my head as she moaned loud. Several others had already finished. The rest followed quickly. We all came. Everyone seemed satisfied. After we got home Kimberly and I were excited again and went for round two, her riding me hard until we both came again.

The next week the chat agreed the oral circle met our needs, yet something felt missing. We could not name it at first. By Wednesday it hit me. Our group likes to compete. We play aggressive poker and want to win. There was no competition here. Maybe we could add some. I floated the idea and everyone agreed. The next day Marcus said he had a solution. He had talked it over with Simone and she thought it was hot. He would explain on Friday.

Competitive Cookie Game

We arrived curious and did not want to wait. Before poker Marcus told us his idea. He had searched Literotica and found the cracker game. Guys jerk off onto a cracker or cookie in the middle. The last one to cum eats it. It would not work as written because it only involved the guys, so he suggested a change. The ladies could masturbate too. The last woman to cum eats half the cookie while the last man eats the other half. Simone thought it would be hot to watch the guys jerk off. Marcus thought it would be hot to watch the ladies. Everyone agreed it sounded great and added real competition. I did not want to eat all that cum. None of the guys did either. We played our games knowing the plan for later. Skill levels dropped because everyone was distracted, cards hitting the table too fast.

When the games ended Marcus brought a large chocolate chip cookie. He broke it in half and set it on a plate. The ladies stripped and sat on the couches. Since a woman’s orgasm is less visible they used the honor system. Marcus started them off. The ladies touched themselves and it was extremely hot, fingers sliding over slick pussies, soft moans filling the room. The men could not touch anyone or themselves but could get as close a view as they wanted. I wanted to make the rounds and see them all up close. Hell, I wanted to fuck them all, but that was off limits. The ladies seemed to find the watching almost as hot as we did. Simone came first. She had probably been thinking about it since Marcus mentioned it. She left no doubt about her huge orgasm, body shaking as she cried out. Kimberly came next. She is easily stimulated so I knew she would not eat the cookie. Lauren and Jennifer followed quickly. It came down to Gianna or Sophie. Both were close, but Sophie finished first. Gianna would eat half the cookie. She offered to eat it now but we told her to wait for the topping.

The guys went next. After watching the women we were all rock hard before we touched ourselves. We could sit or stand but had to announce when ready and approach the cookie. The ladies positioned themselves nearby for a good view. Callum must have liked the idea of his wife eating the cookie. Barely half a minute passed before he announced, approached, and shot all over it. The ladies applauded. Jason and Ric went next, announcing at the same time and shooting from opposite sides. I followed to more applause. Marcus and Nick were last. It was a battle of big dicks. Nick is the thickest and Marcus has two extra inches in length. The girls watched both men jerk hard. Marcus came first. Nick followed right after. That meant Nick and Gianna would eat dessert. Gianna chose a half, though both were drenched. She took a big bite and seemed to enjoy it. She was used to swallowing. Nick was not. He suggested best two out of three but finally ate his half. It took him a while. Everyone except Nick agreed the cookie game was a hit. We could use it going forward.

The cookie game worked well. We used it for over a month and almost everyone ate the jizz-covered cookie at least once. One evening Jennifer suggested a small change. Instead of watching, each spouse could arouse their partner without touching the genitals directly. When the wives masturbated, husbands could suck on their wife’s tits. No touching her pussy. When the husbands jerked, wives could have them suck on their tits. No touching his dick. After a spouse came the partner could move to the next person who had not finished and help. We all thought it was a great idea. I looked forward to sucking on Kimberly’s tits to get her off fast so I could move to another woman. That night Kimberly came very quickly. I moved to Gianna next to her. After Gianna came I sucked on Simone’s tits. I am really turned on by Simone and was thrilled to taste them. Lauren was last among the ladies so she would eat half the cookie.

When the guys jerked I sucked on Kimberly’s tits again. I was so excited I shot first and was the first on the cookie. That let Kimberly move to Ric. After he came she moved to Marcus. Callum was last among the men and ate the other half. We liked the change and decided to rotate between versions.

A few more weeks passed. Everyone kept enjoying the endings. Jennifer had another idea to add to the rotation. This one was a bigger change. The spouse would drive the action. Instead of the wife masturbating herself, her husband would use only his hands to drive her to orgasm. He could suck on her tits but no oral below. When the men went the wives would jerk them off with only their hands. No oral. They could lick their hands to moisten them. Once a spouse came the partner could move to the next person and assist with a hand or by offering a tit to suck. No oral. Everyone agreed Jennifer was a genius with these ideas. I much preferred a woman’s hand on my dick over my own. Ladies went first. I started on Kimberly. I sucked her left tit and worked her pussy lips with my right hand to get her wet. As she loosened I spread the moisture and hit multiple spots. It seemed to work. I realized two hands would be better, one lower to finger her and stroke her perineum while the other stimulated her clit. She enjoyed it. I told her to say if she wanted harder or softer. She said she loved exactly what I was doing. Right after that she exploded in a huge orgasm. One or two others had finished but most were still working. Sophie was next to us. I joined Callum and took one of her tits in my mouth. I added my hand to his on her pussy. That did it. She came hard. The other ladies rolled through their orgasms too. Simone was last. I looked forward to seeing her eat our cum.

✍️ Want a story like this built around your fantasy ? Let an AI write it for you →

The men went next. Kimberly took my dick in hand and put her tit in my face. She knows what she is doing and I normally would not last long after the first round. But I wanted to hold out for a second woman. Even though that risked eating the cookie I wanted to try. I thought of other things to stay in control. Kimberly wondered what she was doing wrong because I stayed only semi-erect. She asked if everything was okay or if she should do something different. I said she was doing great and some days it just took longer. Jason shot soon after. Jennifer moved over. She put her tit in my mouth and added her hand to Kimberly’s. One worked my dick while the other massaged my balls, then they switched. I was in heaven but could not hold out anymore. With their combined touch I knew my time was up. I shot all over the cookie. Luckily I was not last. Nick must have had the same idea. He was still going. He ended up with three women working on him: Lauren, Gianna, and Simone. Even though he would eat the cookie he seemed happy.

The idea of the man trying to hold out while the woman tried to make him cum stayed with me. I thought about it for a few days and came up with another enhancement. This one was significantly different. I posted on the chat that the last activity gave me a new idea and would explain it on Friday. When game night arrived everyone was curious. I told them the idea came after Kimberly tried to make me cum while I tried to hold out for a second woman. Everyone laughed. Kimberly said she knew I was trying not to come. I went on. We could play off that theme. This was more complicated but the prize was better so I hoped they would like it. Instead of a wife giving her husband a hand job, each wife would randomly pick someone other than her husband to jerk. Each pair would have a normal cookie on a plate in front of the man. Her goal would be to make him cum. His goal would be to hold out until at least one other man had come on his cookie. After one man came we would pause. Every man would eat the cookie in front of him. Only one would be cum-covered. He would be the loser. He and his wife would pay the forfeit. The man who lost would lie on the floor. The woman who made him cum would go first, followed by all the others. They could sit on his face, use his hands to get off, and climb on his dick if they could get him hard again. Multiple women could get involved at once in any way they liked until he had satisfied all the ladies.